October 12, 2010 10:30:29 AM PDT
I am relatively new to playing electric guitar and here are a few things I have learned in purchasing the right guitar, at least in my case. I just recently purchased my fourth guitar and have now hit it right. The two main considerations for the "right " guitar for me are: relatively smaller hands and retraining 48 yr old mussels for cord fretting. Hopefully this information will be helpful.
My first guitar purchase was a bass guitar. My thought process was: It has less strings so it should be easier to play. The bass guitar has a longer scale length (neck) then an electric guitar, the neck is thicker and the string gauges are heavier. The short of it is, it is harder to press down (fret) the strings and the longer/thicker neck make it harder on training the mussels.
My next purchase was an electric guitar starter set. The included guitar was Kramer Strat style guitar. What I did not understand at that time was it had a 25.5" scale length and a Fat Boy neck. This pretty much lends to the same issue as the bass guitar, a long and thick neck.
My 3rd purchase was an ESP LTD H-251FM. I had learned about the thick neck at this point and this guitar has a slim taper neck. The scale length was still 25.5". Now I learned about a new concern and a new lesson in guitar purchasing. The new lesson was that I should have played around with the guitar longer at the store. I was kind of embarrassed about my playing ability when plugged into the amp at the store so I did not play it long enough to figure out that the strings on this guitar are much higher off the body. At home I was struggling to reach and pick the Low-E and A strings. What I discovered with this guitar is that they have the neck angled down away from the body. This raises the strings higher off the body. I verified the string heights were set to specs. I measured the string height off the body between the pick-ups and after another trip to the guitar shop, found out they were a solid 1/8" higher then other guitars. (On a side note: I really like this guitar and plan to move back to playing it after I become a more "accomplished" guitarist.)
My fourth purchased addressed all of these issues. I recently purchased an Epiphone Les Paul Standard top guitar. It has a slim taper neck which makes it easier to fret the strings. The neck scale length is 24.75" which means the frets are a little closer together then a 25.5" scale length guitar. The neck on this guitar is set more parallel to the body and the strings are about 3/16" closer to the body then the ESP-LTD which makes it much easier to reach and pick the Low-E and A strings.
The short version of my recommendations for a new guitarist with smaller hands and mussels that need to be developed are: Buy a guitar that has a slim taper neck, 23.75" scale length, verify the neck runs parallel to the body for lower string height off the body and most importantly, spend the time at the store and make sure you are truly comfortable with the guitar you are about to purchase. If you have concerns, talk to the sales rep about them. They may be able to put something else in your hands that address your concerns